how long was cobb in limbo with saitohow long was cobb in limbo with saito

Why didn't Saito kill himself when he was stuck in limbo? Well, setting aside the implications that killing her might have if Mal ever remembered it, the key for Cobb wasn't to simply pull Mal out of limbo. How many layers could you conceivably build into a dream? By clicking Accept all cookies, you agree Stack Exchange can store cookies on your device and disclose information in accordance with our Cookie Policy. rev2023.6.29.43520. This residual Limbo can only have lived on within Cobb's mind - almost like Limbo is his dream. For the Fischer job, Cobb decides the crew needs to go even deeper to really dig into Fischer's subconscious, and he asks for three dream levels. Site design / logo 2023 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA. Later, his brother and fellow screenwriter, Jonathan Nolan, explained to him that "nobody hears that first bit where you say it's really up to the viewers if you then give your interpretation.". Do note that he just can't continue his search for Saito with that fatal stab (because if he did so, he would die before finding Saito and return back to the reality WITHOUT Saito). The one that is the concern at the moment is how they enter through Fischer. Well, consider the opening sequence, when Saito (Ken Watanabe) realizes that the carpet he's lying on isn't as stained as the real one in the actual world. How did Saito get into limbo? Is coming out of a limbo easy or difficult? (Personally I do have a lot of sympathy with your thought that this is a plot hole - but here is a train of thought that might explain it). The Welsh Section D, for example, can be quite fiery and a sharp Read more, EOB, COB and COP in the U.S. is usually at 4:00 pm. Cobb as the only visitor to Limbo has got some more ownership over it than the others until they inhabit it and claim it for their own. When Mal and Cobb went into limbo for the first time it seemed like they were only 1 level down. Nolan seems to understand that regardless of his own authorial intent with the films finale, its audience appeal is in the conversation it started, which will never end. Updated Feb 25, 2023 Cobb and Mal might have spent decades in limbo, but that's equal to less than a day in the waking world, according to the rules of Inception. Therefore, Cobb and Saito would have been trapped in limbo for 182 years if they hadn't been kicked out of the dream. Can the supreme court decision to abolish affirmative action be reversed at any time? If Cobb and Saito hadn't been expelled from Limbo in the film's conclusion, they would have been trapped for approximately 182 years. Was Cobb stuck in a dream at the end of Inception? It's tempting to also use the 1:20 ratio to calculate how much time might have passed for Cobb and Mal on the surface when they were trapped in limbo. When he hands in his passport at immigration at the end of the film, he is clearly not wearing a wedding ring, so its not a dream. While she and Cobb enter Limbo, Eames sets the charges to detonate the fortress to wake them into the previous dream and has Saito defend Fischer. How did Cobb come to the basement using the elevator? Nolan has continually maintained that the ending is subjective and that the only thing that matters is that Cobb doesnt care if hes dreaming or not. In TikZ, is there a (convenient) way to draw two arrow heads pointing inward with two vertical bars and whitespace between (see sketch)? Cobb stops her and tells her to leave him behind. Related: Inception: How Long Cobb & Mal Spent In Limbo (In Real World Time) Mal's shadow stabs Cobb during the film's climax, which throws Cobb back out into Limbo and onto the shores of Saito's Limbo house. So Ariadne jumps off the building; and ultimately wakes up in level 1 due to all the synchronised kicks. By the end of the film, Cobb has just barely completed the Fischer inception job, and he pulled Saito out of limbo while he was at it. That equals about 54 hours under. Which implies that the stab killed Dom and then he should be back to reality, without getting a chance to find Saito and rescue him. What should be included in error messages? Seems kind of off as well, as he would have more than likely found Saito in that time with that method. By the end of the film, those numbers have popped up over and over again throughout the layers of the dream, and they ultimately do open the safe in the third level, which contains the will that convinces Fischer to break up his father's companies, thus completing the inception. Why was Saito old but Cobb wasnt? Possibly because he knew Mal was the more prominent subconscious threat and was doing his best to fight her. How Long Saito Was In Limbo Before Cobb Found Him. So, it is possible to commit suicide even if you are in limbo. All rights reserved. If you kick yourself out of the 3rd layer and reach the second layer, no problem. What Should I Look For In Corn On The Cob? He must have judged it from the foreign nature of the environment. Time works differently than in real life in each dream level in Inception: the team's 10-hour flight is one week in the first level, six months in the second one, and 10 years in the third.As Yusuf's chemical compound doesn't allow Cobb and company to go deeper than three levels, the fourth one would be Limbo, and as expected, time works very differently in this space. Something like this and "Cobb could see a new sub conscious material entering the limbo space, which means that Saito died" could be given as an explanation to those who ask how Cobb found where Saito was when in limbo. Many different interpretations of the final scene exist online, many with compelling evidence to back up their claims, and you can certainly pick your own interpretation. How do Cobb and Ariadne enter Limbo without having to die? Should Cobb succeed in doing so, Saito promises to clear Cobb's criminal status, which would allow him to finally return home to his children in the United States. The fourth level was a dream that looked like limbo. Reddit, Inc. 2023. There are some fans who would definitely argue that he was, as evidenced by the lack of aging in his children and the possibility that he and Mal didn't wake up from limbo into reality but instead into another layer of a dream that he hasn't escaped from. If yes, then what happens to a person who dies in limbo? He follows the team into the third level, a snowy mountain where he volunteers to led Fischer to the hospital fortress where the inception will be finalized while Eames distracts the Fischer's subconscious projections and Cobb and Ariadne provide cover for Fischer. They must have got a reason to do so. When Cobb and Arthur's attempt to steal secrets from him fails, Saito reveals that he was testing them for a job and offers to hire them to perform inception on Robert Fischer, the son of Saito's biggest rival, to dissolve his father's business empire. In the hotel dream, Saito is primarily an observer. Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information. Stack Exchange network consists of 182 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. Due to this state, the fact he wasn't quite dead, this would account for the normal time dilation. Christopher Nolan Wiki is a FANDOM Movies Community. Ariadne and Cobb have only been in limbo a few minutes or perhaps a few hours, which would only be a very short time in the dream layer above, but perhaps Cobb through his stronger connection with Limbo and the world he created in it, he can sense that Saito has died and entered it with them. So when Fischer gets shot he enters a 4th level (since the heavy sedative cant make people wake up). Saito grew to be an old man, and Cobb reminded them they had a mission. Ariadne successfully retrieves Fisher, Cobb stays behind in limbo to retrieve Saito, whose wounds also plunged him to limb but I really dont have time to tell you about that in full, and the team gets off the 10-hour flight from Australia to Los Angeles. What is an English cob? It meant that she firmly believed in the reality (which was their shared dream) which she was in. Yes, I also thought the same might be the case. Bastian964 12:09, January 3, 2012 (UTC), I'm sorry but I'm not going to spend the effort to reread the entire script to find information that was long established by many other editors. Manage all your favorite fandoms in one place! Cause Cobb says (after Fischer gets shot), "His mind's already trapped down there." Ariadne and Cobb have only been in limbo a few minutes or perhaps a few hours, which would only be a very short time in the dream layer above, but perhaps Cobb through his stronger connection with Limbo and the world he created in it, he can sense that Saito has died and entered it with them. Why is Saito much older than Cobb in Limbo? Cobb and Saito got out of limbo by waiting until the sedative ran out (and they were normal-asleep) then they shot themselves, thus waking up. Cobb and Mal might have spent decades in limbo, but that's equal to less than a day in the waking world, according to the rules of Inception. Inception: All The Evidence Cobb Is Still Dreaming In The Final Scene At this point all I really do is curate the wiki to make sure no one messes it up. Starting the Prompt Design Site: A New Home in our Stack Exchange Neighborhood, Statement from SO: June 5, 2023 Moderator Action. What they didn't count on was a train suddenly crashing through traffic and disrupting their efforts. What is the term for a thing instantiated by saying it? He may not know with 100% confidence but biased on how long it looked like Saito had to live, and how much time has pass he can say with a fair degree of certainty that Saito is dead by now, Agree with aidenO. Manage all your favorite fandoms in one place! Saito might have been there, but was too far away. How Long Was Cobb In Limbo In Real Life? There's no definitive, authorial answer to the ending of Inception because Christopher Nolan really would, in this case, like you to make up your own mind. Going by Caines words, however, his appearance in the scene confirms the events were all real. Yet while in Limbo, Cobb performed Inception, which according to that article it's done by dream-sharing (ie, going deeper into someone's mind). The rise of dream sharing When Cobb ( Leonardo DiCaprio) and his crew first recruit Ariadne (Elliot Page) to be the architect for the Fischer inception job, they have to begin to let her in on. Nolan chose Inception, a high-concept, sci-fi action film about a group of people who construct elaborate dream worlds to infiltrate people's minds and steal ideas from them. Could you make a dream with four tiers or five or six? It is a fact that Cobb and mal stayed in Limbo for 50 years, and it is also fact that 20x is the standard for time dilation. Cobb briefly left Limbo when Mal died (possibly but highly unlikely) Cobb was so distracted when Mal died that it somehow resulted in him returning to Limbo location #1, the Beach (possible but unlikely) Cobb has spent years searching Limbo for Saito's fortress. Why didn't Saito kill himself when he was stuck in limbo? rev2023.6.29.43520. And in the cityscape, it basically leaps out of Cobb's subconscious and into the dream because his guilt is so invasive that it can get in the way even when he's not the dreamer or the subject. How to cycle through set amount of numbers and loop using geometry nodes? Or if the second layer collapsed, presumably the third layer would collapse, which would destroy the first layer as a result. They simply went deeper, and somehow reached that world from his old memories. At the beginning of the film, Arthur and Cobb are pulling an extraction job on Saito, who ultimately hires them to conduct the inception job on Robert Fischer (Cillian Murphy). After wasting much time in finding the answer to this question, I think I've got one. It ends on the pan. Through Saito's memory of Cobb's totem and . The dreamers all awaken on the plane, and Saito makes a phone call. Leaving Limbo Cobb and Mal manage to leave Limbo by committing suicide, presumably straight into the waking world. During the first level of the dream, an imitation of New York, the team unexpectedly learn that Fischer's subconscious is militarized for his protection and Saito is shot when the team is attacked by a group of armed projections, forcing Cobb to reveal the true danger of the job. In the deeper levels of the dream, Saito's injury does not impede him as the time dilation in the lower levels mean the injury is taking longer to affect him. What episode does Saito come back to life? Cobb's not going to try anytime soon, but it's interesting to think about. Inception Ending Explained - Is Cobb Still Dreaming? But Fischer is "dead", so we have instant Limbo. Although dying in a dream normally wakes the dreamer, the sedation required for the job means that death in the dream will drop the dreamer into Limbo, a dreamspace of raw subconscious and no limitations, resulting in the dreamer losing their sense of reality and time. Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information. The fourth level (where Fischer is alive after being shot by Mal) IS limbo. What time of day is cob? However, he doesn't have enough time to escape (and he doesn't want to - he has to go get Saito), so he dies on level 1. He dies protecting these dreaming people - Fischer, Cobb and Ariadne in the Snow Fortress in third level. In the first scene, Saito asks Cobb "Have you come to kill me?" What the theory stipulates is that if someone were to try to host more than one dream, the dream would instead change. Bastian964 13:23, April 12, 2012 (UTC), LALALALALALALALALALALALAL LOLLIPOPS, OH GOD I CHOKED ON ONE, NOT HAHAHAHA GULLIBLE FOOLS. From the script: I know that making the distinction between Cobb and Ariadne first suggesting that Saito is dead seems very nitpicky, as we can ask the same question 'how does he know?'. Browse other questions tagged, Start here for a quick overview of the site, Detailed answers to any questions you might have, Discuss the workings and policies of this site. The corridor . Within that dream world, Cobb and his crew have to abduct Fischer as he's catching a taxi, then take him to a warehouse and begin the process of inception. Over a decade since the movie's theatrical release, many still wonder why Saito is old at the end of Inception. How long were Cobb and Saito in Limbo? Why would a god stop using an avatar's body? That wasn't why he said it wasn't. He sometimes calls his children on the phone, and he even chances a trip to Paris to pass along gifts for them via his father (Michael Caine), but he can't go back home until he finds a way to "buy" his way back. Ariadne returns from Limbo and joins the rest of the team to awaken in the collapsing levels of the dream while Cobb remains in Limbo to find Saito, having anticipated that Saito has died in the time taken to find Fischer and overcome the projection of Mal. The way the film is structured suggests the idea of limbo as a kind of bottom for the characters, but how much dream space could exist between a third level and that? When Cobb's crew first get to the level 1 dream we are told that if they die in the dream their brain will turn to mush since the chemist used some new 'stronger' prescription. Ariadne didn't design a 4th level. How long was Cobb and Saito in limbo? One proof being Cobb presuming to find Saito there. What is an English cob? By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. That's all. It ultimately doesn't matter much to the story because the main thrust of the plot is in the inception job, but his past is particularly important in the context of the ending. Limbo is the wild west and is a culmination of subconscious. What the film doesn't establish, though, is exactly when it became clear that totems were necessary. Does it stop spinning at the end of Inception? The order of events is: Fischer dies in level-3 (reaching Limbo) Cobb and Ariadne sleep in level-3 (reaching Limbo) Saito dies in level-1 (reaching Limbo) Mal stabs Cobb in Limbo and gets shot Louise doesnt even try to hide her happinness and accepts it wholeheartedly. Note (again) this is after Saito's death, so what is moments for Cobb is a lifetime for Saito. Explanation of how Cobb re-enters limbo twice and age How do Cobb and Ariadne enter Limbo without having to die? Later on, we learn that this is limbo. Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. Here's all the evidence that he is. And that's how he was able to rescue Saito. This makes exiting the dream entirely impossible. Cobb clearly figured this out before Mal did, so why didn't he just kill her in limbo, then kill himself so they could wake up together? Indeed, Yusef did say that it was impossible to go into three dream layers, but they pulled it off in the movie under sedation. 3/7/2021. Through his influence, he provides the opportunity for the team to isolate and sedate Fischer so they can enter his dreams long enough to plant the intended idea and even buys out an entire airline so that the team can accompany Fischer on a 10-hour flight to Los Angeles. Backtrack to level 1, where Saito is dead and Cobb is alive. Well, it's the same train that Mal and Cobb used to kill themselves while in limbo, to take themselves up and out of their dream state. A level up that would mean 912.5 days. Stack Exchange network consists of 182 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. Using the 1:20 ratio, 10 hours of reality actually equals 8.3 days of dreaming on the first level, 5.47 months on the second, and 9.1 years on the third. So, has he only been gone for a few months, or has he simply lost his grip on reality? Movies & TV Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for movie and TV enthusiasts. Why Is Saito So Much Older Than Cobb In The Final Dream Level? Both struggle to remember their situation, but slowly regain memories of their lives in the real world. Is there any advantage to a longer term CD that has a lower interest rate than a shorter term CD? Wouldn't he also have been much older than Cob. Presumably this is to make the action sequences become meaningful. Inception begins with Cobb waking up or lying on the beach in the water. Finally, Cobb, noticing the constantly spinning totem, gives Saito the message that their world is not real. Why was it necessary to rescue Saito from limbo? We see Cobb being stabbed by Mal in 4th level of dream (which is presumably limbo); does that give him a shock to rise up to the third, then to the second, and ultimately to the first level (where he dies due to drowning)? Blessing or not? So Cobb died in Level 1, and then of course in limbo. There's a catch, though. Cobs are often considered as the most suitable horses for beginners, but not all of them are fit for first-time horse owners. In the beginning of Inception, Cobb is working overseas, and we slowly learn that it's not by choice. This is a far better answer in my opinion. What does the spinning top at the end of Inception mean? Does that imply limbo is just a state of mind and can be reached at any level the dreamer desires? It wasn't about the numbers. The beach just happens to be where we catch up with him (this imho is the most . Why did Arthur not wake up from the first kick? He is brought before Saito. You descend into limbo. It is a fact that Cobb and mal stayed in Limbo for 50 years, and it is also fact that 20x is the standard for time dilation. Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. Published by Clayton Newton on November 29, 2022 50 years. For each level they select a specific dreamer to set the stage. Therefore, she no longer needed the totem. Are they searching the minds of their partners to find proof of infidelity? The film establishes that limbo is difficult to escape because it's hard for your mind to realize you're there, but if you do want to escape, you can do so by dying. According to this article, Limbo is the deepest one can travel in the mind. Cobs are often considered as the most suitable horses for beginners, but not all of them are fit for first-time horse owners. GDPR: Can a city request deletion of all personal data that uses a certain domain for logins? Why is there a drink called = "hand-made lemon duck-feces fragrance"? And he dies again in limbo when shot by Saito, and then wakes up in reality directly. The Saito job is a "dream within a dream" extraction, and it's implied that doubling up on dream worlds like that is both difficult and at least somewhat rare within the world of dream sharing. They wake up from limbo directly, just as Mal and Cobb once woke up directly from limbo. Saito | Christopher Nolan Wiki | Fandom 14 Answers Sorted by: 35 The implication is that once you are in unconstructed dream space, you lose track of reality over time, and time passes really quickly. I seem to have a problem with the time dilation. Cobb carries a little top with him. But why is it the train and not Mal? By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. I had a bit of a problem with manually entering Limbo with going down levels. How long did Cobb and Mal spend in limbo? Inception: How Long Cobb & Mal Spent In Limbo (In Real World Time) Published by Jennifer Webster on November 29, 2022. Years later in Limbo, Cobb washes ashore and is brought into a large palace ruled by Saito, who has grown old in the dream world. Cobb and Saito got out of limbo by waiting until the sedative ran out (and they were normal-asleep) then they shot themselves, thus waking up. By clicking Accept all cookies, you agree Stack Exchange can store cookies on your device and disclose information in accordance with our Cookie Policy. Let's say that level 3 is the absolute limit you can go down. Source: reddit. Is it appropriate to ask for an hourly compensation for take-home interview tasks which exceed a certain time limit? Subscribe to Updates Get the latest creative news from FooBar about art, design and business. When Fischer claims he doesn't know it, Cobb demands the first six numbers that pop into Fischer's head, and Fischer responds with 528491. Cookies help us deliver our Services. ), but it says that no person can be the dreamer (or host) of more than one dream at a time. And what I mean by that is the different methods of going into Limbo. Only this time, instead of taking an idea out, they have to put an idea in and not get caught while doing it. Am I missing something or is it a mistake? Because he entered before Saito did, it is now his dream. analysis - Why does Cobb wake up in the water? - Movies & TV Stack Exchange Why didn't Saito kill himself when he was stuck in limbo? The Biggest Unanswered Questions In Inception - Looper Now for something different. How Long Cobb & Mal Spent In Limbo (In Real World Time) In 2010, Christopher Nolan was one of the hottest blockbuster directors working in Hollywood. It makes things more clear when people say, for example, I think c! Is he in the real world at the end of Inception? Originally they would have been Read more. When Cobb (Leonardo DiCaprio) and his crew first recruit Ariadne (Elliot Page) to be the architect for the Fischer inception job, they have to begin to let her in on all the various rules and procedures that come with the field of dream sharing. If it falls, he is awake. How to professionally decline nightlife drinking with colleagues on international trip to Japan? and our Cobb and Mal, however, kept going forward. In movie that means he either blows up, immediately dies without firing weapon or in this case is dead by now. Though his plan only worked initially and failed later, the point was to make her want to leave. In truth, the scenes underlying meaning, as we read it, is that Cobb is still dreaming, and his dreams are his new home in the last scene. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top, Not the answer you're looking for? plot explanation - Why was Saito old in Limbo? - Movies & TV Stack Exchange I don't remember this particular thing being said in the movie, but still a very large number of people believe it. Inception Plot Holes Airtight Interactive I'll leave it to others to decide. In the Fischer inception job, the first level of the dream isa relatively simple rainy cityscape. Because Fischer himself dreamed them up. In Inception Cobb tells Ariadne that he was stuck in limbo with Mal for 50 years. Why was it necessary to rescue Saito from limbo? Heres What The Script Actually Says Basically, if the top keeps spinning, Leos character is still dreaming. John Waynes Monument Valley Horseback Ride, Wyatt Earps Vendetta Ride Tombstone Arizona Territory. If three layers isn't enough to coax inception with a strong subconscious, could you go further? Why Is Cobalt Used In Rechargeable Batteries? To reach limbo deliberately, you have to kill yourself in a dream world while being heavily sedated, or you would have to enter too many dreams within dreams, as that is how Cobb and Mal reached limbo due to instability caused by too many nested dreams. They aren't even similar. So, was Cobb still dreaming? If two is the limit, like Yusef said, then they couldn't have reached a place of infinite time dilation (or enough time dilation to account for the 50 years). When Mal kills Fischer in level 3, then Cobb and Ariadne use a briefcase to go another level down, why do they automatically go into limbo?